Following one-line method basically a ruby alias alternative, one-line is good. def go_to end def goto; go_to; end def go; go_to; end But will always be format to following form: def go_to end def goto go_to end def go go_to end I consider it’s unnecessary

This is a subjective matter. In my opinion this: def foo; bar; end is less readable than this: def foo bar end If we allow the two forms then people will start making comments like “Hey, you should make this a one-liner” and so on. By not having the option to choose everything is simplified.

[Discuss] Formatter always format one-line method to multi-line, is it necessary?

Help & Support

Blacksmoke16 Split this topic February 21, 2023, 2:18pm 7

A post was split to a new topic: Compiler error assigning nil to instance var

Topic		Replies	Views
Some question(or improvement?) for Crystal Crystal Contrib	9	539	May 12, 2022
Line continuation character Help & Support	10	238	February 23, 2023
[RFC] Don't special-case `IO#puts(String)` Crystal Contrib	16	472	March 5, 2022
Discusson about & Crystal Contrib	2	129	January 8, 2024
Coding style: Your preference in multi-lines instruction styling?	2	344	April 1, 2019

[Discuss] Formatter always format one-line method to multi-line, is it necessary?

Related Topics